Never Toss Mushrooms Again! Smart Storage Tips to Keep Them Fresh Longer

Mushrooms pack a punch with their umami kick and meaty texture, but the real challenge lies in keeping them fresh. These delicate delights are notoriously quick to spoil unless you know the proper storage tips to keep them fresh. We’re spilling the secrets on how to store mushrooms perfectly, from fridge tips to freezing hacks.

Choosing Mushrooms

Keeping mushrooms fresh for as long as possible starts with how you buy them from the grocery store or farmer’s market. Opt for those that feel firm, look dry and smell earthy — signs they’re at their peak. 

Stores that keep mushrooms open to the air in baskets are best. However, if your only option is a plastic-wrapped container in the refrigerated produce section, look for accumulated water inside the package. Despite being composed of 90% water, mushrooms don’t take well to water. In excess, water will spread bacteria and create that slimy film we all dread before even having a chance to cook them.

Different Methods for How to Store Mushrooms

Before we jump into the variety of storage options that work best for storing mushrooms, it’s important to note that all these methods assume you’re storing whole mushrooms. While it may be tempting to prep and clean mushrooms when you get home from the store, they’ll last longer when kept whole. That’s why it’s not uncommon to see sliced mushrooms in packages already turning slimy in the store.

Option 1: Storing Mushrooms in Their Original Container

For most of us, this is probably the most popular mushroom storage method out there — buy the container of mushrooms and throw it in the fridge when you get home from the store until you’re ready to toss them in a soup or serve them alongside a ribeye steak. Despite its simplicity, this method works fine if you only store the mushrooms for a short time.

If you’re not planning to use the mushrooms within three days, keep reading. Otherwise, there’s nothing wrong with this approach. Of course, it depends on how fresh the mushrooms look, to begin with, but two to three days are usually short enough to avoid any water accumulation underneath the plastic wrap, which will eventually spoil the mushrooms.

Option 2: Bowl With Paper Towels

This method works well for medium-duration storage of about four to five days. To do this, line a large bowl with paper towels. The size of the bowl is important so the mushrooms have plenty of room to breathe and not be packed tight against each other. Cover the top of the bowl with more paper towels.

The paper towels help absorb any moisture coming off the mushrooms and condensation from the refrigerator. This method is nice because, unlike the previous approach, where adjusting the plastic to check on the mushrooms would break the seal, you can easily remove the top paper towels to gauge their freshness throughout the week and meal plan accordingly.

Option 3: Paper Bag

Considering this is how any vendor at a farmer’s market will hand you your freshly purchased mushrooms, I would’ve expected this to be the best way to store mushrooms. While it’s not too shabby, it’s not the front-runner either.

This approach is good for a medium to long-term storage duration and should keep most of the sliminess away for five to seven days; there may be a few discolored spots on the mushrooms towards the end of that timeframe. The consensus, however, is that discoloration isn’t necessarily problematic when eating mushrooms. In fact, Cook’s Illustrated says those spots on white button mushrooms may even lead to a more robust, earthier flavor than unblemished mushrooms. Use them in a stroganoff for an even more comforting flavor if that’s the case.

Option 4: Paper Bag With Paper Towels

The winning mushroom storage option combines the best of both worlds — a paper bag with paper towels. Its double protection against moisture will keep mushrooms the freshest for the longest period. You can safely expect mushrooms stored in this manner to last seven to eight days, but up to 10 days isn’t out of the question.

Line a brown paper bag with folded paper towels and dump in the mushrooms. The paper bag and the paper towels work overtime to soak up the moisture created in the refrigerator. 

While these four storage options are the most common, you can certainly play around with other methods and experiment with what works best for you. Zuzana Paar from Best Clean Eating cleans all the mushrooms after foraging and leaves them to dry in a shaded area. Once they’re dry and ready for storage, she then places the mushrooms in a glass container or a plastic bag with a few bay leaves inside and claims they stay fresh for a month that way. 

The Biggest Takeaways

With mushroom consumption on the rise as a new wellness trend, knowing how to store them is more important than ever. Plastic is a mushroom’s worst enemy. It traps moisture and causes dampness, which results in the mushrooms becoming slimy, discolored and even moldy. To play it safe, use all mushrooms within three to five days of purchasing. However, if you absolutely must store them longer, take the extra effort and store them in a brown paper bag with paper towels to get the longest shelf life out of them.

Top Storage Tips To Read Next:

This article originally appeared on Food Drink Life.